Wet Dog Food Review
Blue Buffalo Family Favorite Recipes Wet Dog Food Review
An editorial review of blue buffalo family favorite recipes wet dog food covering ingredients, nutrient profile, recipe quality, AAFCO suitability, cost, recalls and overall value.
- Author: Samuel James
- Published: June 07, 2026
- Updated: june 07, 2026
No. of Recipes
4
Recipe Reviewed
1
Line Rating
4.2 / 5
Rating Range
4.2 to 4.4
As a Chewy affiliate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Ingredient Analysis
Nutrient Analysis
Cost Analysis
Recall Check
On This Page
Products List
Representative Recipe Reviewed
★★★★★ 4.2
This dog food line has 4 recipes. Reviewing all isn’t possible. The review of Shepherd's Pie Recipe shows the quality, nutrition, and composition of the whole line.
Ingredients
Beef, Beef Broth, Water, Beef Liver, Chicken, Dried Egg, Potatoes, Peas, Carrots, Potato Starch, Guar Gum, Salt, Sodium Phosphate, Caramel Color, Calcium Carbonate, Potassium Chloride, Natural Flavor, Choline Chloride, Zinc Amino Acid Chelate, Iron Amino Acid Chelate, Vitamin E Supplement, Copper Amino Acid Chelate, Manganese Amino Acid Chelate, Sodium Selenite, Thiamine Mononitrate (Vitamin B1), Cobalt Amino Acid Chelate, Niacin Supplement (Vitamin B3), Calcium Pantothenate (Vitamin B5), Vitamin A Supplement, Riboflavin Supplement (Vitamin B2), Biotin (Vitamin B7), Vitamin B12 Supplement, Potassium Iodide, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride (Vitamin B6), Vitamin D3 Supplement, Folic Acid (Vitamin B9).
Ingredients are listed in descending order by pre-cooked weight, which can affect how ingredients appear near the top of the list.
Ingredient Analysis
This Blue Buffalo Family Favorite Recipes Wet Dog Food Review highlights the first five items as the formula’s primary ingredients.
Primary Ingredients
Beef
Beef is a named meat ingredient. It can provide protein that helps support muscles and body tissues, along with fat that helps supply energy and flavor. Because fresh beef contains a lot of water, its place on the label may look stronger than its final share after cooking.
Why It Matters
A high position suggests meat content, but moisture can make fresh beef seem heavier than it is.
Beef Broth
Beef broth is a liquid ingredient made by cooking animal parts or muscle tissue. It mainly adds moisture and flavor, and moisture has value because water is an essential nutrient. Still, broth is usually less important for protein than meat or meal, especially because liquid ingredients can rank high by weight.
Why It Matters
It can help with moisture and taste, but it should not be weighed like concentrated beef.
Water
Water is commonly used in wet dog food to add moisture, help ingredients mix evenly, and support the soft texture expected in canned, pouch, or tray-style foods. It does not add protein, fat, or major nutrients by itself, but it can make the food easier to chew and more palatable.
Why It Matters
In wet food, water mainly supports moisture, texture, and processing. Its importance depends on the full recipe.
Beef Liver
Beef liver is a named organ ingredient. It can add animal protein, flavor, and nutrients found in organ tissue, including vitamin A, B vitamins, iron, and copper. Because liver is nutrient-dense, even a smaller amount can matter in a recipe. Its value depends on placement, amount, and the full nutrient balance of the food.
Why It Matters
It can add flavor and organ-based nutrients, even when used in a smaller amount.
Chicken
Chicken is a named poultry ingredient. It can add protein that helps build and renew body tissues, along with fat that helps supply energy. Because it is a fresh ingredient and labels are ordered by weight, its place on the list may look stronger than its final dry share after cooking.
Why It Matters
A high spot suggests real chicken content, but fresh chicken can look heavier on the label than after processing.
Secondary Ingredients
This Blue Buffalo Family Favorite Recipes Wet Dog Food Review looks at the next four items as the formula’s secondary ingredients.
Dried Egg
Dried egg is an egg ingredient with moisture removed. It can add egg-based animal protein, fat, and nutrients naturally found in eggs. Because it is dried, it is more concentrated than fresh egg by weight.
Potatoes
Potatoes are a plant-based carbohydrate ingredient. They can add starch that may contribute calories and help support the texture and body of the wet food. When properly cooked, potato is also sometimes used as a gluten-free carbohydrate option in certain feeding situations.
Peas
Peas are pulse ingredients. They may contribute starch for energy, plant protein, and fiber. Because peas contain several nutrients, they can play more than one role in a formula. Their value depends on amount, placement, and how they fit with the rest of the recipe.
Carrots
Carrots are a vegetable ingredient. They can provide carbohydrates and may contribute fiber. Carrots are also known sources of beta-carotene, so in dog food they are usually better read as a supporting plant ingredient. Their overall importance still depends on how much is used in the formula.
Other Notable Ingredients
This review of Blue Buffalo Family Favorite Recipes Wet Dog Food also notes other notable ingredients that appear further down the list.
Potato Starch
Potato starch is a carbohydrate ingredient made from potatoes. In wet dog food, it may add digestible starch for energy and can also help thicken, bind, or support the texture of the food.
Guar Gum
Guar gum is a plant-based gum ingredient used mainly for texture. In wet dog food, it can help thicken, bind, or stabilize the food so the gravy, loaf, or pate holds together better. It is not a major protein or fat source.
Ingredients Takeaway
This recipe appears to build its animal ingredient base around beef, beef liver, chicken, and dried egg, with broth and water supporting the wet texture.
Its carbohydrate structure is led by potatoes and peas, with carrots and potato starch adding plant-based support.
Overall, the profile is fairly clear, though it relies on added vitamins and minerals.
Nutrient Sources
We analyzed this Shepherd’s Pie Recipe to identify the likely ingredient sources of protein, fat, carbohydrates, and fiber, along with its likely vitamin and mineral contributors.
Protein Sources
Protein appears to come mainly from named animal ingredients, including beef, beef liver, chicken, and dried egg. Beef is listed first, though its fresh weight includes moisture, while dried egg may provide a more concentrated contribution by weight.
Beef
Beef Liver
Chicken
Dried Egg
+ others
Fat Sources
Fat is likely supplied mostly by the beef, beef liver, chicken, and dried egg in the recipe. The formula does not list a separate named oil or fat source, so the fat profile appears to come primarily from the animal and egg ingredients.
Beef
Beef Liver
Chicken
Dried Egg
+ others
Carbohydrate Sources
Carbohydrates appear to come mainly from potatoes, peas, carrots, and potato starch. Potatoes and potato starch likely provide much of the starch structure, while peas and carrots may add smaller plant-based carbohydrate contributions.
Potatoes
Peas
Carrots
Potato Starch
+ others
Fiber Sources
Fiber appears to come mainly from peas and carrots, with potatoes likely adding a smaller amount of plant-based fiber. Guar gum may also contribute some soluble fiber, although its main role in this type of wet food is likely texture and thickening rather than serving as a primary fiber source.
Peas
Carrots
Guar Gum
+ others
Vitamins: Likely Food-Based Sources
Beef liver, chicken, dried egg, peas, and carrots may naturally contribute some vitamins to the recipe. That said, the ingredient list also includes several added vitamin supplements, so the formula does not appear to rely on food ingredients alone for its vitamin content.
Minerals: Likely Food-Based Sources
Beef, beef liver, chicken, dried egg, peas, and carrots may naturally contribute some minerals. However, the formula also includes added mineral sources such as calcium carbonate, potassium chloride, zinc amino acid chelate, iron amino acid chelate, copper amino acid chelate, manganese amino acid chelate, sodium selenite, cobalt amino acid chelate, and potassium iodide.
Ingredient Concerns
Things to consider
What Stands Out Positively
This formula appears to start with clearly named animal ingredients, including beef, beef liver, chicken, and dried egg. Some owners may appreciate that the primary animal ingredients are specific, with beef liver adding an organ-based component and dried egg offering a concentrated animal-derived ingredient.
What May Concern Some Owners
Some owners may note that beef and chicken are fresh ingredients, so their high placement partly reflects moisture before processing.
From an ingredient-list perspective, the recipe also uses potatoes and potato starch separately, alongside peas, which suggests some ingredient splitting may be seen within the plant-based carbohydrate portion of the formula.
Natural flavor and caramel color may give some buyers pause, although the list alone does not show how much they contribute.
Overall Concern Level for Blue Buffalo Family Favorite Recipes Wet Dog Food
Minor. Based on the label alone, the ingredient concerns appear limited and mostly tied to normal interpretation of wet-food ingredient order, plant-based starch ingredients, and a few smaller additives. Overall, the formula appears reasonably straightforward from an ingredient perspective, with no major ingredient-level concern evident from the list alone.
Nutrient Analysis
We analyzed this recipe using guaranteed analysis, dry matter basis, and calorie basis to better understand its macronutrient profile.
Protein (Dry Matter Basis)
44.4%
Fat (Dry Matter Basis)
27.8%
Carbohydrates (Dry Matter Basis)
11.1%
Fiber (Dry Matter Basis)
5.6%
Method of Analysis | Protein | Fat | Carbs |
|---|---|---|---|
Guaranteed Analysis | 8% | 5% | 2% |
Dry Matter Basis | 44.4% | 27.8% | 11.1% |
Calorie Basis | 36.1% | 54.8% | 9.0% |
Interpretation: This recipe is high in protein, high in fat, and low in carbohydrates on a dry matter basis.
This interpretation is based on our editorial comparison tool and is intended for general review purposes only. It is not an official product claim or a statement from the manufacturer.
AAFCO and FEDIAF Comparison
This section compares the recipe’s estimated dry matter protein and fat levels with AAFCO and FEDIAF minimums for adult maintenance.
Adult Maintenance
Standard | Protein (min.) | Fat (min.) |
|---|---|---|
AAFCO | 18.0% | 5.5% |
FEDIAF (110 kcal/kg) | 18.0% | 5.5% |
FEDIAF (95 kcal/kg) | 21.0% | 5.5% |
Recipe Estimate | 44.4% | 27.8% |
Based on the estimated dry matter values, this recipe appears to exceed both the AAFCO and FEDIAF adult maintenance minimums for protein and fat.
"BLUE Shepherd’s Pie Food for Dogs is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for maintenance."
What that statement means
This statement indicates that BLUE Shepherd’s Pie Food for Dogs is formulated to meet AAFCO nutrient levels for maintenance.
From the label wording, it appears intended for adult dogs rather than puppies, growth, gestation, or lactation unless another statement says otherwise. The adequacy claim appears to be based on formulation to AAFCO nutrient profiles, not on feeding trials.
That does not say more about ingredient quality by itself, but it does clarify the food’s intended nutritional use as a maintenance diet.
Cost Analysis
We compared the available buying options to understand upfront cost, cost per ounce, and overall value of Blue Buffalo Family Favorite Recipes Shepherd's Pie Canned Dog Food.
Price Interpretation
The pricing shown suggests a straightforward case-based structure rather than a comparison across multiple pack sizes. Since no smaller or larger option is visible, the available data only supports interpreting this recipe at $3.00 per can and $0.24 per oz.
Autoship Note
At the time of review, the retailer listed an Autoship offer of 35% off the first order (up to $20), with future Autoship orders priced about 5% below the one-time purchase option.
To check the current price, Autoship savings, and availability, use the retailer link at the bottom of the screen.
Pros and Considerations
Pros
• Named animal ingredients form the primary protein base
• Beef liver adds a clear organ-based ingredient
• Low carbohydrate estimate on a dry matter basis
• Meets AAFCO adult maintenance formulation standard
Cons
• Natural flavor and caramel color may concern some owners
• Potatoes and potato starch appear separately
Recall and Safety
Recall History
We found no FDA recall notices for this brand in FDA Recalls & Withdrawals records reviewed from 2019 to present.
Last Checked
June 07, 2026
Recall Monitoring Note
Recall status may change over time as new FDA notices are announced.
Stay Updated on Dog Food Recalls
Join our recall alerts list to get notified when new dog food recall notices are announced.
Our Rating
Reviewed Recipe Rating
4.2/5
Editorial score for the specific recipe reviewed on this page.
Editorial Verdict: Very Good
84 / 100
Ingredient Quality
4.0/5
Ingredient Safety
4.5 / 5
Processing
3.5/5
What influenced this recipe score
• Multiple named animal proteins appear near the top, supporting the ingredient quality assessment.
• Protein is strong on a dry matter basis, while carbohydrate load remains low for wet food.
• Natural flavor and possible potato ingredient splitting were noted as modest formulation considerations.
Product Line Average: 4.2 / 5
This reflects the average editorial score across reviewed recipes in this dog food line.
This rating reflects our independent editorial opinion of the specific recipe reviewed, based on the information available at the time of publication. It is not intended to disparage the brand or company, and other reviewers may reasonably reach different conclusions.
Final Verdict
Who This Food May Suit
Blue Buffalo Family Favorite Recipes Shepherd’s Pie Canned Dog Food may suit owners looking for a canned adult maintenance recipe built around named animal ingredients, including beef, beef liver, chicken, and dried egg. It may also appeal to buyers who value a high dry matter protein estimate and a relatively low carbohydrate profile for wet food.
Who May Want an Alternative
Owners looking for a recipe for puppies, growth, gestation, or lactation may want a different option, since the label statement points to adult maintenance.
Owners comparing lower-fat wet foods may also want to review alternatives, since this recipe’s fat estimate is high on a dry matter basis.
Buyers who prefer to avoid natural flavor, caramel color, or potato-based starch ingredients may also want to compare alternatives.
Overall Editorial Verdict
Overall, this recipe earns a positive editorial assessment, with a 4.2 out of 5 rating and a “Very Good” verdict. Its main strengths are the named animal ingredient base, strong dry matter protein level, and low carbohydrate estimate. The main considerations include natural flavor, caramel color, and possible potato ingredient splitting.
This review is for informational purposes and is not a substitute for individual veterinary advice.
More Blue Buffalo Reviews
More Formulas to Consider
Same flavor alternative
Grain-free with wholesome animal protein.
Different Flavor Option
Protein-rich chicken, turkey, and egg wet stew.
More Reviews
Editorial Note
Samuel James
Independent editorial dog food reviews
Affiliate-supported content
DogFoodNet provides clear, editorial dog food reviews that look beyond marketing claims. Each review evaluates ingredient quality, nutrition data, and pricing to help you understand what a recipe may offer, where it may fall short, and whether it appears to fit your dog’s needs and budget.
Focus: ingredients, nutrition, cost, and buyer guidance
Independent editorial review process
Affiliate disclosure: commissions may be earned from qualifying purchases
Have a question about this review? You can contact us anytime with your questions, feedback, or suggestions.